Enemy at the gate book review

A stronghold well stocked with food, water and ammunition as Vienna was could hold out for a long time, but tunnels could reach under even the mightiest bastions, and gunpowder would then bring them down. I also found him interesting because he loved to run and how I made him feel good!.

She was motivated to join the war as a means to avenge her grandparents who were murdered by the invading Germans. In my opinion, Stalingrad is a way better movie than the Hollywood one. And Tania Chernova was more badass than the film leads one to believe.

This book gives a fine account of the siege itself, and of the subsequent siege and capture of Buda by the Habsburgs, which led to the expulsion of the Ottomans from central Hungary.

Enemy at the Gates: The Battle for Stalingrad

Probably, the director believes that our grandfathers fought only from fear, that if it was up to them, they would've ran away, and nobody would've been left to fight the valiant German army.

But by then, Zaitsev was married for more than 15 years to another woman. A single shot from his lone antitank gun put one enemy panzer out of action and machine-gun fire scattered the German infantry. For example, the Dzerhezinsky Tractor Works in Stalingrad, the assembly point for thousands of farm machines, which since the war was one of the principal producers of T tanks for the Red Army, ran for more than a mile along the main north-south road.

The famous sharpshooter, Vassili Zaitsev had killed nearly forty Germans in ten days time, and correspondents gloatingly wrote of his amazing ability to destroy his enemies with a single bullet. Even if you overlook the British accent of Jude Law while depicting a real life Russian hero Vassili Zaitsev He could have at least tried to sound more like a Russian, to give the movie an authentic feelthe film never fails to disappoint.

On the Russian side, Vasily Ivanovich Chuikov was made commanding general of the 62nd Army, which was to hold Stalingrad itself. They also became lovers. The battle of Stalingrad cost the lives of nearly 2 million men and women. After "neutralizing" Russian war production in that region by bombing and artillery fire, and after cutting the vital transportation line on the Volga, both army groups were to turn south and drive on the oil fields of the Caucasus.

While his parents and ten year old brother stayed inside their house, the diminutive, frail Sacha went out to fraternize with the enemy. The Russians in Stalingrad hid in cellars and used the sewer systems to good advantage. A character in this book that was interesting for me would be Tom because through out the book it shows how e feels and how much he is hurting.

And Stalingrad was full of such factories which was a real achievement for the socialist regime.

User Reviews

Danilov suddenly raised himself up, shouting: This tactic also rendered the German Luftwaffe ineffective, since they could not attack Red Army positions without firing upon their own forces. The third morning, Zaitsev had a new visitor, a political agitator named Danilov, who came along to witness the contest.

His end was bad as depicted in the movie but more depressing. Army Group B, under Fedor von Bock, boasted the Fourth Panzer and Sixth armies, which were to be aided by the Hungarians in support of their rear echelons.

He was interviewed by Vasily Grossman during the battle and the account of that interview, lightly fictionalized in his novel, Life and Fate[7] is substantially the same as that shown in the movie without naming the German sniper with whom he dueled. Critics claimed that it simplified history and glorified war.

User Reviews

The army groups were to move eastward on a broad front to the line of the Volga River "in the area of" the city of Stalingrad. The city was not even a primary target for attack. After the war ended, a census found only 1, people who had lived in Stalingrad in When Annaud focuses on that, the movie works with rare concentration.

When Annaud focuses on that, the movie works with rare concentration. Pitched battles between armies in the open field were a different matter, however.

Enemy at the Gates

But he survived and Tania came to know of his survival only after more than two decades. Andrew Wheatcroft has read widely among 17th-century printed accounts, and has an in-depth knowledge of Habsburg history.

Craig's narrative falls into that military genre which charges each moment with dramatic significance; he follows foot soldiers, doctors, quartermasters, generals, snipers and sappers on both sides through the terrible five-month battle in which half a million combatants and countless civilians died.

Captain Ignacy Changar was an expert guerrilla fighter and preferred to work with a knife—a technique he had perfected in the forests of the Ukraine, where he spent months during the first year of the war. Siege warfare played to their strengths: My favourtie quote in this book would be: Robbinswhich is a fictionalized account of the duel between two sharpshooters in the warzone of Stalingrad.

It was of extreme importance because it was the last stronghold protecting the vast oil fields that lay beyond it to the east. Tania Chernova was one of his students. In other words - complete rubbish.

Paulus as indicated by William Craig stopped annihilation of the Jews by the 6th Army which was done by clockwork precision until Paulus took over the command from his predecessor. Once four tanks came and fired pointblank into the building.

Review: The Enemy at the Gate by Andrew Wheatcroft. This book gives a fine account of the siege itself, and of the subsequent siege and capture of Buda by the Habsburgs, which led to the. "Enemy at the Gates" Craig Williams was born in Concord Massachusetts.

Book Review: Enemy at the Gates

He wrote the book "Enemy at the Gates" in The point of this book was to show both the extreme importance of this battle in the course of World War II and the courage of both the. Don't even harbor the thought that the film version of "Enemy at the Gates" bears anything but cursory relation to this book.

The movie was actually based on a fictionalized book called "War of the Rats." If you want to read one book about the Hell that was World War II, this is the one/5. Enemy at the Gates completely misrepresents the history of the battle and slanders the brave sacrifice of the Soviet people to defeat Nazism.

I strongly recommend reading the book 'Enemy at the Gates' to see how little of the movie is true. Enemy at the Gates: The Battle for Stalingrad - Kindle edition by William Craig.

Download it once and read it on your Kindle device, PC, phones or tablets. reached the top ten on the New York Times bestseller list and was deemed “virtually flawless” by the New York Times Book Review/5().

Enemy at the Gates has 9, ratings and reviews.

Enemy At The Gate

Lyn said: A study of World War II is an exercise in tragedy. To compare it to a Greek or even Shake /5.

Enemy at the gate book review
Rated 5/5 based on 21 review
Enemy at the Gates: The Battle for Stalingrad - William Craig - Google Books